Mounting concern for carrot growers on emergency approval for neonicotinoids

by Peter Crowe

There is mounting concern among UK carrot growers that the Government is dragging its feet over granting emergency authorisation for the use of neonicotinoid seed treatment (Cruiser 70WS). The application has been considered by the Expert Committee on Pesticides (ECP) and is now awaiting a decision by Ministers.

Ian Holmes, R&D Chairman of the British Carrot Growers Association said: “There is real concern in the industry because this seed treatment is the most effective way we have to control early aphid-transmitted viruses and foliar applied products do not provide the same activity. We have had an Extension of Authorisation for Minor Use (EAMU) within the UK for several seasons and this has helped keep a lid on virus infection in crops. If we don’t get approval soon it could be disastrous.

“Coming on the back of one of the most difficult growing seasons in living memory, this would be a real blow to British carrot growers at a time when we need all the UK-grown fresh produce we can get. Furthermore, news that growers in Belgium have recently received emergency authorisation for the same product means that the UK carrot growing industry will be at a significant competitive disadvantage to our European counterparts.   

“We are not asking for an indefinite approval, but need the next couple of years to find new solutions to this problem. However, without neonicotinoid seed treatment ßin the short term, the industry could face real issues with crop quality and yield.”